Why The Flash failed at the box office, according to its director

Andy Muschietti discusses the problems of his star, Ezra Miller, but also the lack of popularity of the DC superhero.

Released in theaters at the beginning of 2023, The Flash ofAndy Muschietti was troubled by delays, reshoots and its star's mental health issues, Ezra Miller. Mixed reviews sealed the fate of the film, which caused Warner Bros. to lose approximately $200 million during its theatrical run.

Who is really responsible for this flop ? Muschietti? Miller? The new studio boss, David Zaslav? The first has obviously not been reprimanded by the managers of the firm, since he is still supposed to stage The Brave and the Bold for the DCU of James Gunn and Peter Safran. The director, however, recognizes this failure, and he gives several reasons why he thinks that The Flash did not find its audience.

Interviewed in Spanish about this by Radio TUand relayed by Real Anarchyhe speaks openly “mental health problems” of its main actor, accused, on the sidelines of his production, of having attacked fans, consumed drugs in the presence of children, manipulated psychologically fragile young women…

Did DC's new strategy cause The Flash to flop?

“This failure, it was the result of dealing with a mental health problem, you know, he begins. That's how it happened, let's say. I mean they [Miller] was dealing with a mental health issue, and when you make a film, there are things you can't control. One of them is the public relations crisis that the actors are going through. They had problems during this period, there was the arrest in Hawaii, etc. Personally, I had a very good experience with Ezra. He is a great actor, a great comedian, who surprised me a lot. And then, towards the end, I discovered all this…

Muschietti clarifies that it is not only Ezra Miller's crises which are responsible for the failure of The Flash. He also places the blame on the character himself, saying he just wasn't as popular with moviegoers, especially females, as Batman or Superman, for example.

“When you spend $200 million on a movie, Warner wants even your grandmother to go to the movies, he explains. And I found in private conversations that a lot of people just weren't interested in Flash as a character. Particularly the female audience.”

Muschietti does not mention the fact that he arrived on this project following the abandonment of five directors, and that the firm had to hire numerous screenwriters to rethink The Flash currently in production, but this inevitably weighed on its reception in theaters. The film was also released at a time when the DCEU was being completely redesigned by Warner Bros., the films of the “Snyderverse” having to leave the field open to those supervised by James Gunn.

A big superhero film to be released in 2023 had 45 screenwriters

At the writing of Firstwe quite liked it The Flash. Here is an extract from our criticalfollowed by the film's trailer:

Paradox: The Flashthe fastest superhero in the DC universe will have taken its time to arrive on our screens. (…) First evidence, Ezra Miller is a perfect Flash ! Until then he had been confined to the role of the rookie and the comic element (particularly in the Justice League by Whedon). We discover here that the actor is capable of injecting real emotion into the character. This is due to its composition, but also to the most interesting trick of the scenario. The story very quickly pits two Barry Allens against each other. (…) There has been a lot of talk about superhero cameos, the appearance of Zod and figures from the past, or the return of Michael Keaton as Batman. But Muschietti – who after Mama and the two chapters of That moves away from flamboyant horror – stays focused on its hero. The first 20 minutes of the film, very amusing (the saving of the babies, Barry's complex within the Justice League, Wonder Woman's lasso of truth) function as a sequel to Justice Leagueand serve to define the original Barry before launching the film when the latter begins to go back in time.

Nicolas Cage is even more afraid of AI since The Flash